In a humorous holiday episode of
Mystery Science Theater 3000, the Devil is invited to a Thanksgiving dinner where he is asked to tell everyone what he is thankful for. He looks up and replies, "Pat Robertson." It's a funny joke, but many Christians do feel as if Mr. Robertson is playing for the other team. His odd remarks about Haiti have only continued this trend, because what he said was foolish and completely un-biblical.
What, Exactly, Did He Say?
Here's what he said on The 700 Club, on January 13th:
“Something happened a long time ago in Haiti, and people might not want to talk about it,” Robertson said on his Christian Broadcasting Network show. “They were under the heel of the French … and they got together and swore a pact to the devil. They said, ‘We will serve you if you’ll get us free from the French.’ “True story. And the devil said, ‘OK, it’s a deal,”‘ Robertson said. “Ever since, they have been cursed by one thing after another.” French historians were quick to point out
the flaws in his history lesson.Is That Sort of Thing in the Bible?
Christianity does not work this way. No part of scripture tells us that God intends to allow natural disasters to overcome any country that involves themselves in sin. Obviously, if things worked this way the Nazis could not have come into power, Stalin would have been struck by lightening, and nations that broadcast pornography during prime time would suffer yearly droughts.
No, there's no precedent for this nonsense in Christianity. Sure, in the Old Testament God punished people as he saw fit, but the Bible doesn't establish a predictable formula for this sort of thing; in fact, His preferred method was to establish good relations with those nations. (See Jonah, for example.)
A lot of questions are unanswered. For starters, how did a bunch of Haitians find the Devil? Does he have a house around there, or is there a way to summon him that French slaves were privy to? Pat Robertson never works this stuff out and the Bible doesn't make it clear that this sort of thing is even possible. The whole story is ridiculous and sounds more like pagan mythology than any part of Christianity.
So...Where Does Pat Robertson Get This Stuff?Pat Robertson makes news every few months with failed predictions of the future; he has predicted natural disasters and terror attacks that never materialized - often accompanied by the phrase "...that is, if I heard God correctly..." (I don't remember Isaiah ever saying that.) Other times, he is issuing condemnations, like claiming that homosexuals were responsible for Hurricane Katrina; this is a ridiculous notion that is not supported by any statement in the Bible. We are expected to take Robertson's word for it that he is God's prophet, but none of his "prophecies" come true.
So, I don't know where he is coming from. He's certainly not talking about the God that is worshiped at local churches all over the world, nor is he discussing things that are founded in the Bible. The church fathers didn't talk this way, and, for that matter, neither did the villains of the inquisition.
I'm glad that Pat Robertson raised money for Haiti (which is what he was doing when he made these statements), but his message is not the same one that comes from the Bible. I'm not sure what he's doing.
I also don't know who's listening to him; in my entire life, I've never met anyone, in church or elsewhere, who didn't roll their eyes when his name was mentioned.
(
Update: Welcome Instapundit readers! Thanks, Glenn.)