Halloween isn't a problem, for me. I'm sure you've heard that it's a holiday for the Devil or that demons walk the Earth on that day disguised as candy corn or something. The truth is, no one can trace the roots of Halloween very well because each culture has its own seemingly ancient background for the holiday. Personally, I've always thought it was neat to have a day when we all remember those things that we fear and put them in perspective. (Which doesn't explain why I dressed up as a robot, one year. Halloween really doesn't make any sense.) Anyway, it seemed like a waste of time, to me, to set up a church festival that socially opposed Halloween.
But, things have changed. Does anyone let their kids Trick-or-Treat, anymore? The threat of receiving poison in candy has been wildly overstated, but the idea of letting kids wander the streets is less appealing with every episode of the evening news - harvest festivals have become the only safe option for some parents.
It's no longer relevant to use harvest festivals to oppose Halloween, instead, it's about safety and fun. A church or community can work together to give the kids a fun evening without the threat of predators and such. I've slowly come around to the harvest festival bandwagon and I think that they provide many memorable Halloween memories for kids.
But I certainly don't want to see Halloween go away. I would regret it if Halloween lost its Victorian Gothic identity and the romance that goes with it. So, I'm not interested in toppling Halloween and advocating church alternatives like a social holiday usurper, but I've learned that Harvest Festivals have a lot more to offer than I originally thought - so I'll leave them alone.